Insurer pays for full roof after offering to fix one side
An engineer found wind damage on all four slopes, not just one.
The questionDoes an insurer have to pay for a whole roof, or only the damaged side?

This outcome concerns one matter. Different facts and laws may produce different results.
TULSA, Okla. — A Tulsa homeowner has received $33,700 for a full roof replacement after challenging her insurer's offer to repair only the slope facing a spring windstorm.
The insurer's adjuster found damage on one side of the roof. Her roofer found it on all four.
A partial repair would have left damaged sections in place and created a mismatched roof.
Brisvane Legal obtained a second inspection by a licensed engineer, who documented lifted and creased shingles on every slope, and pointed to the policy's matching provision.
The insurer revised its estimate and paid $33,700.
The homeowner paid her deductible. Gutter damage was disputed and not included.
Whether a full replacement is owed depends on the damage and the policy's wording, so independent inspections are often worth the cost.
About this story
This is a sample story, written to show how case stories will appear on Result.law. It is not a real case, and Brisvane Legal is not a real law firm. See our publication standards.



